Shorts and Two tone shirt

[HR Solutions]

I have another question. Last week a candidate came for an interview with us dressed in denim shorts, a two tone shirt, short socks with contractors boots. I would be interested to hear what people out there think about this.

To answer some of the things that might be brought up:
Yes he has got the qualifications for the relevant job spec
Yes we did interview him
And yes we did then refer him on to the client, that same day (dressed the same)

How would you, if you were the client first of all expect a potential new employee to be dressed that you had to interview etc etc ?


Ps. I am not really interested in what the law says. I do not want this thread to go like the other thread.
I know the law. I am asking for people's opinion.

[adrianh]

Depends on the position. If he is being interviewed for a position as an accountant I would not be happy, if he was being interviewed for a position as a golfing range groundsman it would perfectly ok.

[HR Solutions]

He was in actual fact being interviewed for an electrical engineers job. Do you think the client would be happy to see him arrive this way or would you not think that the client would think that he could not even bother to smarten up a bit, therefore he might not be that serious about the position ?

[IanF]

So if he gets the job then you know you can't judge a book by it's cover!

[HR Solutions]

So if he gets the job then you know you can't judge a book by it's cover!

Yes you are right Ian. But please just in case you were thinking this, I was not. I am just trying to get other peoples perspective out there. Times are changing.

[ians]

That how I dress everyday , living in Durban it is HOT...HOT and sweaty.

I went to a meeting with a new customer today, I could see I got the whole look me up and down not really consultant type dress code, but by the time the meeting was completed I think he realised I know my sh!t, what would you have a really well dressed idiot or a person who works in comfortable clothes and knows what he is talking about...you know my response to this question.

[adrianh]

I think there is a bit more to it. One needs to dress appropriately for the occasion. The appropriate dress is not to necessarily make yourself look nice, it is generally more to show respect for the host, guests and the occasion. We wear sombre clothes to a funeral, formal clothes to a wedding, a smart outfit when you take your lady to a supper club (well at least I do...I don't want to embarrass her by me dressing like a twat when she did her level best to look her best)...etc.

The fact that the person feels comfortable in a speedo and plakkies does not mean that he should disrespect his host, which in this case happens to be the person interviewing him who probably expects a certain degree of curtsey and respect. I'd love to see him get into a swanky restaurant dressed like that, I bet he wouldn't even try!

[pmbguy]

"Denim shorts, a two tone shirt, short socks with contractors boots" its just his style, don't know if I could pull that look off. The way somebody is dressed affects our perception of that person, definitely. It is logical that your appearance should be appropriate for what you may be doing at the time. But obviously the way a person behaves, attitude, manners, intellect, skill ect is much more important. If that guy really does want the job he would change his jean pant if so wished by the employer.

[AndyD]

I don't have an opinion so much as an observation. They say first impressions are everything.... but.... if you under dress and have got the personality, communication skills and the qualifications and knowledge to pull it off then it can actually work in your favour where it will be considered as an 'endearing quirk'. On the other hand if you don't have the entire package to go with it it could easily be your downfall. It's similar to that anti-hero thing where bad boy turned good will always be more popular than a plain old goodie two shoes

[HR Solutions]

I think it will depend on if he can impress the client or not.
Lol I will certainly keep you updated on what the client says and if he gets the job. ��

[Mike C]

I think that how a person dresses does impact on the way we feel about ourselves as well as the impression that is made on others.

There is an interesting study on this found here:

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/brain-babble/201208/clothes-make-the-man-literally

Having said this, however, it seems as though times are a-changing. No longer are people dressing up to go to the theatre, or to church, or even to wedding functions. Even if an invitation calls for dress as "black-tie" no one is turned away because they are not "dressed properly".

On the one hand it could be said that we are moving to a healthier outlook in that we need not dress for others and that they need to accept us as we are. Are we in the process of changing the acceptable norms of society or could it be that we are simply becoming disrespectful of others (and some may say even of ourselves)?

[Dave S]

I have seen a CEO for a major corporation that came to a meeting dressed in a pair of denims and a golf shirt, it didn't detract from the fact that he knew his business, and moreover, he commanded attention. Lot's of other exec's around the table were commenting on his dress, but it soon became apparent that this was someone you wanted to listen to. Times have changed and "The clothes maketh the man" is an obsolete statement.

In my trade (Mechanical) I like to see a man/woman that looks like he/she, can and has, worked before. I once interviewed a mechanic who was dressed in his Sunday best at the interview, but his hands were rough and rugged, it showed that despite the dress, he was a worker, he eventually went on to take over one of the workshops that was problematic and he turned it around in a very short space.

[ians]

Let tell you about another incident which affected the outcome, I went to site to do a small job (was told a small job turns out it was the second biggest contract I have done since I started my business) little company with small team. I dress funny (shorts and Tee shirt sometimes) and I was told I have 2 weeks work(working on the pace of the contractor on site), I finished my little 2 week job in 3 days and left. I was the only person on site with short pants a Tee shirt and takkies. When I arrived on site I could see the expression on the boss mans face. When I left after the 3rd day, I thought I would never get work there again.

I was contacted a week later and I took over the project and ended up being one of the only contractors on site who completed on time, moral of the story don't be fooled the cover, if you an idiot with shorts on, you will still be an idiot wearing a suit.

[Dave S]

"A monkey in silk is a monkey no less" - Rodrigeus

[adrianh]

Will you guys go to a funeral or a wedding in shorts and a t-shirt?